Free to use · No signup needed to run any tool
All tools

Powered by DealIQ

Strategy Comparison

Enter a property’s figures once and see how it performs as a buy-to-let, BRR, HMO, serviced accommodation or rent-to-rent deal, side by side.

  • 5 strategies
  • Side by side
  • Same figures

Indicative only. Built from published rules and the figures you enter; we do not guarantee accuracy or completeness, and this is not tax, legal or financial advice. Check with a qualified professional before relying on it. How accurate is this?

Our take

The same house can be a poor let and a strong HMO

This runs one property through buy-to-let, buy-refurbish-refinance, HMO, serviced accommodation and rent-to-rent side by side, so you compare cashflow, ROI and a DealIQ score from your own figures and not from a rule of thumb.

DealIQ is arithmetic and not AI: it rewards positive monthly cashflow, healthy returns and buying below market value, and flags negative cashflow hard, so a weak score tells you about the inputs as much as the strategy.

Be wary of the most profitable column, because higher returns usually mean more work, more compliance or more risk, and rent-to-rent and short-let results rely on control of a property and not ownership of it.

Pick the two strategies that look strongest and test them properly in their own calculators, then take the winner into a deal pack.

Our opinion, based on the official sources named above: general guidance, not regulated advice and not a forecast. We earn from OfferCheck reports and from introducing sellers to cash buyers, so weigh it with that in mind (see our disclosure). We are not authorised or regulated by the FCA.

Your figures

Enter the property once: every strategy below recalculates instantly.

Property & finance

£
£0£1,000,000
£
£0£1,000,000
£
£0£200,000
£
£0£20,000
%
0%100%
%
0%100%
%
0%15%
£
£0£1,000,000

Income

£
£0£5,000
£
£0£5,000
£
£0£500
%
0%100%

Costs & setup

£
£0£1,500
%
0%30%
£
£0£50,000

Buy-to-Let

PASS65/100
Cashflow (self, pcm)
£431
ROI (self)
8.0%
Gross yield
8.7%
All-in capital
£64,600

Positive £431/month cashflow at 8.0% ROI and 8.7% gross yield. This stacks up.

Open calculator

BRR / BRRR

PASS65/100
Cashflow (self, pcm)
£431
ROI (self)
8.0%
Gross yield
8.7%
All-in capital
£64,600
Money left in
£27,100

Positive £431/month cashflow at 8.0% ROI and 8.7% gross yield. This stacks up.

Open calculator

HMO

PASS65/100
Cashflow (self, pcm)
£431
ROI (self)
8.0%
Gross yield
8.7%
All-in capital
£64,600

Positive £431/month cashflow at 8.0% ROI and 8.7% gross yield. This stacks up.

Open calculator

Serviced Accommodation

PASS100/100
Cashflow (self, pcm)
£676
ROI (self)
90.1%
Gross yield
—
All-in capital
£9,000

Positive £676/month cashflow at 90.1% ROI. This stacks up.

Open calculator

Rent-to-Rent

FAIL22/100
Cashflow (self, pcm)
£50
ROI (self)
6.7%
Gross yield
—
All-in capital
£9,000

Weak returns: 6.7% ROI. The numbers don't justify the capital and risk.

Open calculator

How to read this

Each column runs the same property through a different strategy and gives it a DealIQ verdict (🟢 PASS · 🟡 CAUTION · 🔴 FAIL) from cashflow, ROI, yield and BMV. Control strategies (Rent-to-Rent, Serviced Accommodation) have no purchase, so yield and BMV don't apply. They're shown as “ ”. Share this comparison with the link in your address bar.

Estimates only, based on the figures you enter. Not financial advice. Verify with a qualified professional. Individual BTL landlords: mortgage-interest relief is restricted (Section 24).

This calculator is for guidance only and does not constitute financial, tax, mortgage or investment advice. Figures are estimates, always seek professional advice and verify costs before committing to a purchase.

Comparing property strategies: common questions

Which property investment strategy is most profitable?
It depends entirely on the property and your capital. The same house can be a weak buy-to-let but a strong HMO, or an excellent BRR if it adds enough value to refinance your money out. Enter your figures above and compare cashflow, ROI and the DealIQ verdict across all five strategies at once. The numbers decide, not a rule of thumb.
What do BTL, BRR, HMO, SA and R2R mean?
BTL = Buy-to-Let (buy, let to one household). BRR = Buy, Refurbish, Refinance (add value, pull your capital back out). HMO = House in Multiple Occupation (let by the room). SA = Serviced Accommodation (short-stay / nightly lets). R2R = Rent-to-Rent (you rent from the landlord and sublet, no purchase). Rent-to-Rent and SA-by-lease are control strategies, so yield and below-market-value don’t apply to them.
How is the DealIQ verdict calculated?
DealIQ is a deterministic 0–100 score from your own figures. It rewards positive monthly cashflow, healthy ROI, gross yield and buying below market value, and flags negative cashflow hard. It is maths, not AI, and never invents numbers. PASS / CAUTION / FAIL follows the score.
Can I share my comparison?
Yes, your figures are saved into the page URL as you type, so just copy the link from your address bar. Anyone who opens it sees the exact same comparison.

Investor? Build a deal pack

Turn these numbers into an investor-ready pack

A branded PDF (comparables, costs, a map and charts) to present a deal or raise finance on. £4.99 a pack, or unlimited for £29.99/yr.